Pre-Work Card Problems during the Pandemic Period – The way the Pre-Work Card is launched by the government is more like a shopping card with the provisions that some of the funds must be spent on products in the form of videos and materials provided by all designated training start-ups. After that, then the card owner gets an incentive. In other words, the government is like building an “online mall” specifically for training, and all start-ups that are cooperated are the merchants. The card is not too different from shopping cards in supermarkets, for example, although the context is different.
With a regular shopping card, the buyer gets a discount when shopping at certain outlets and the price of the item after deduction will be debited from the buyer’s banking account. In the Pre-Employment Card, the balance is given by the government with funds in the name of training that can only be used in the “online mall” to pay for videos and other forms of material that are claimed to provide various kinds of skills.
But the material offered there is generally widely available on the Internet or the YouTube platform and it’s free too. So, the Pre-Employment Card balance to buy training material valued at Rp 1 million per person is actually not right for prospective job seekers. This method is more appropriate for school children who apply learning at home.
Pre-Work Card Problems during the Pandemic Period
First, there is a superficiality of the meaning of skills and expertise in this policy, which is only limited to watching videos and reading material. Unlike the case with online tutoring, for example, which is targeted to face the students’ written examinations. Skills and expertise, as intended by the government for Pre-Work Card problems holders, are actually more dominant elements of experience alias practice and direct evidence.
Why is someone said to be “good” or have ability in a field? That’s because he has experience or repeatedly practiced this, not only because he has been watching videos from the field from morning to night. Thus, vocational training centers and training institutions, which provide knowledge as well as practice the knowledge with prospective workers, are the frontline and the best in forming prospective workers. Watching and getting material from all the start-ups involved, even if certified online, is not a solution to turn prospective new workers into ready-to-use workers.
Second, job seekers, or just call it unemployed, are a workforce that has not been productive, aka not having an income. That is, this segment has not been able to meet all its own needs. This is an assumption under normal conditions, before there is economic pressure from the corona virus outbreak or Covid-19. In other words, economic pressures due to corona outbreaks will further complicate their condition. Their chances of getting a job or business will shrink because the economic situation is deteriorating.
Then suddenly the government gave a card whose balance was not to meet their basic needs, but rather to buy content that they could actually search for themselves on Google or YouTube. Wouldn’t this hurt? There is a balance and a hungry stomach, but can not afford to buy rice and side dishes. There is indeed an incentive of Rp. 600 thousand per month for several months in this program, but it is provided through the financial technology platform involved. In addition, these funds can only be obtained after spending Rp 1 million for videos and training materials provided by the start-ups involved.
In short, the Pre-Work Card is another name for the start-up “product purchase project” in collaboration with many training institutions for Rp. 1 million on behalf of 5.6 million job seekers or a total value of Rp. 5.6 trillion, without a tender anyway, on when employment is running low and storms of termination of employment are haunting. As a result, funds that could have been used to feed and sustain the lives of 5.6 million people from the workforce who had not worked just moved first into the pocket of start-ups and training institutions, then only job seekers could get other incentives. If not, next year the names of job seekers will be crossed out. Poker Online Jakarta
Third, the funds released have almost no velocity, are not productive for the national gross domestic product (GDP) because they do not really enter the real sector, do not produce any products or commodities in real terms, which involve many new workers. This is different from buying 1 kilogram of rice for one person, for example. If 5.6 million people buy rice, 5.6 million kilograms of rice will be absorbed.
Imagine how much the multiple impact. People buy rice to traders who buy it from rice wholesalers. Rice wholesalers also take it from traders who buy directly from farmers. Then the farmer pays part of his income to buy the necessities of life, partly to buy seeds and fertilizer to the cooperative. From the cooperative, the money can go into the bank again or be lent again to the cooperative members and keep spinning again. Each transaction point will be calculated as GDP. So, buying rice will help far more parties than paying for training content that is less contextual to the needs of the current situation.